INDIANS AT FOUR-YEAR SCHOOLS
| YEAR | NAME | SIGNED WITH |
| 1976 | Buck Showalter | Mississippi State University |
| Russel Aldrich | Mississippi State University | |
| Craig Robinson | Southern Illinois University | |
| John Stamper | University of Florida | |
| David Mobley | Florida State University | |
| Lloyd Ard | Florida International University | |
| Steve Weiss | Florida International University | |
| 1977 | Matthew Gaglione | Florida Southern College |
| John Lackey | Florida Southern College | |
| Price Westbrook | University of South Carolina | |
| Kenny Fox | Western Kentucky | |
| 1983 | Mark Higgins | University of New Orleans |
| Willie Smith | Jackson State University | |
| Buck Watford | Troy State University | |
| Shawn Adams | Auburn University | |
| Jeff Hendry | Florida Atlantic University | |
| Mike Workman | Florida Southern University | |
| Alain Paternaude | University of Miami | |
| Mark Marino | University of South Alabama | |
| Glen Jenkins | University of South Carolina | |
| Mark Rose | University of South Florida | |
| Grover Jackson | Jackson State University | |
| 1984 | Ed Gonzales | Florida International University |
| David Lunsford | Western Kentucky University | |
| Mike Lee | Florida State University | |
| Robin Hart | University of Georgia | |
| 1985 | Todd Englett | Troy State University |
| Jimmy Hitt | Florida Southern University | |
| Paul Pederson | University of Central Florida | |
| Scott Sweinhart | Huntingdon College | |
| John Simon | University of Mississippi | |
| Donnie Denton | University of West Florida | |
| John Clements | Columbus College | |
| Alan Platt | University of Central Florida | |
| Mike Sandler | University of Alabama | |
| Jim Law | University of Kentucky | |
| Marshall Oliver | University of So. Mississippi | |
| Jay Scott | University of Central Florida | |
| 1986 | Felix Rosario | Northwestern State University |
| Juan Escalante | Marion College | |
| Edwin Alicea | Florida State University | |
| Pete Brown | University of Alabama | |
| Paul Lewis | Birmingham Southern College | |
| Vince Santelmo | Fort Hays State University | |
| Scott Hughes | Warner Southern College | |
| 1987 | Scott Spate | Columbus College |
| Joe Gonnella | Florida International University | |
| Kyle Haines | University of North Florida | |
| Joe Logan | Florida Southern College | |
| Bill Madril | University of West Florida | |
| Raphael Perez | University of South Alabama | |
| Sal Argila | Auburn University - Montgomery | |
| Rolando Fernandez | Northwestern State University | |
| 1988 | Greg Hammond | University of Alabama |
| Adam Bigale | University of Montevallo | |
| Don'L Dease | Samford University | |
| Jeff Kilpatrick | Florida Southern College | |
| Brian Gilliland | Florida State University | |
| Jorge Rosario | Columbus College | |
| Ivan Alicea | Columbus College | |
| Kenny Turner | Warner Southern College | |
| 1989 | Joe Myrick | Valdosta State University |
| Ed Alford | Troy State University | |
| Joel Smith | Troy State University | |
| Mike Jeffcoat | University of West Florida | |
| Charlie Ebright | Georgia Southwestern College | |
| 1990 | Jason Smith | University of West Florida |
| Roland Tollett | Louisiana Tech University | |
| Tim Christman | Florida Southern College | |
| Bret Anderson | University of West Florida | |
| Juan DeBrand | University of Alabama | |
| Chet Frady | Columbus College | |
| D.D. Cannon | University of Tennessee | |
| Mike Brown | Columbus College | |
| Andy Dolson | Troy State University | |
| Jeff Brown | Troy State University | |
| Rodney Ashby | Liberty University | |
| David Brazil | Valdosta State University | |
| Walter Rivera | Columbus College | |
| Clayton Brewer | Valdosta State University | |
| David Perry | University of South Alabama | |
| 1991 | Steve Charles | Troy State University |
| Tommy Lee | Nova University | |
| Karun Jackson | University of West Florida | |
| Rob Beaver | Jacksonville State University | |
| Corey Jackson | University of Tampa | |
| 1992 | Bernie Bellard | University of Alabama |
| Bobby Jones | University of Alabama | |
| Paul Bryant | Troy State University | |
| Will Green | Troy State University | |
| Kevin Millican | SE Louisiana University | |
| Greg Slone | Western Kentucky University | |
| K.C. Stephens | University of West Florida | |
| 1993 | Anthony Dubose | University of Alabama |
| Sean Gerrard | University of North Alabama | |
| Jason Cox | Jacksonville State University | |
| Steve Green | University of Kentucky | |
| 1994 | Bobby Hughes | Auburn University - Montgomery |
| Timmy Young | University of Alabama | |
| Adam Faurot | Florida State University | |
| Chad Gainey | Jacksonville State University | |
| Mike Cespedes | Columbus College | |
| Kenny Davis | Georgia Southwestern College | |
| Brian McDevitt | Kennesaw State University | |
| 1995 | Kenny Arnold | Univ of Alabama - Huntsville |
| Bailey Chancey | Univ of Alabama - Huntsville | |
| Thornton Davis | University of Central Florida | |
| Noel Elizor | Univ of Alabama - Huntsville | |
| David Barinowski | University of West Georgia | |
| 1996 | Adam Mercer | University of Central Florida |
| Jeff Sloan | University of Central Florida | |
| Trey Hussey | Troy State University | |
| Antonio Bostic | University of Alabama | |
| Alberto Morales | University of North Alabama | |
| Jeremy Miller | Henderson State | |
| 1997 | Brady Frederick | Auburn-Montgomery University |
| Matt Triplett | Auburn-Montgomery University | |
| Troy Wells | Faulkner University | |
| Elio Bejaran | Faulkner University | |
| Brad Harris | Loyola University | |
| 1998 | Desmond Baxter | University of New Orleans |
| Brent Fowler | University of West Georgia | |
| Michael Mitchell | Faulkner University | |
| Tranum McLemore | Auburn-Montgomery University | |
| Grant Conyers | Jacksonville University | |
| Luc Riopel | Winthrop University | |
| David Credeur | Florida International University | |
| Brad Weis | Auburn University | |
| Phillip Sledge | University of Georgia | |
| Matt Steele | University of Georgia | |
| Ben Saxon | Louisiana State University | |
| Steven Budde Jr. | Loyola University | |
| 1999 | Brennan Dees | University of South Carolina |
| Lane Floyd | Kennesaw State University | |
| Cameron Likely | University of South Alabama | |
|
2000 |
Michael Brown |
Mississippi State University |
|
|
Caleb Crosby |
University of South Alabama |
|
|
Max Havel |
University of Georgia |
|
|
Justin Lord |
Florida State University |
|
|
Jake Mathis |
Univ of Alabama-Huntsville |
|
|
Drew Miller |
Troy State University |
|
|
Richie Smith |
Florida State University |
|
|
Blake Taylor |
University of South Carolina |
|
|
Fernando Isa |
University of Louisville |
|
|
Moises Feliz |
Cumberland University |
|
|
Nathan Marks |
Auburn-Montgomery University |
| 2001 | Jonathan Swearingen | University of Mississippi |
| Kyle Olson | Univ of Alabama-Huntsville | |
| Lee Poteet | Troy State University | |
| Josh Plaice | University of South Alabama | |
| Phillip Slusher | University of North Alabama | |
| 2002 | Blake Balkcom | Florida State University |
| Eric Bernier | Florida A&M University | |
| Chad Coffee | Georgia Southwestern Univ | |
| Troy Fry | Berry University | |
| Les Hassen | Florida Gulf Coast University | |
| Ivan Naccarata | Louisiana State University | |
| Ricardo Nanita | Florida International University | |
| Scott Wearne | Nichols State University | |
| Clay Wehner | Univ of N. Carolina-Greensboro | |
| Randy Roth | Southeastern Louisiana Univ | |
| Trent Hebert | Southeastern Louisiana Univ | |
| 2003 | Victor Alvarez | Cumberland University |
| Adam Dunavant | Central Missouri State University | |
| Matt Grooms | University of Alabama | |
| Rocky Scelfo | University of Alabama | |
| Joey Wilson | Stetson University | |
| 2004 | Jay Mattox | East Carolina University |
| J.P. Lowen | University of Kentucky | |
| Barrett Browning | Florida State University | |
| Daniel Forrer | LSU/Auburn-Montgomery Univ | |
| Alan Horne | University of Florida | |
| Jeff Bosse | Stetson University | |
| Ken Brown | University of Alabama | |
| Jake Baker | Faulkner University | |
| Jonathan Woodcox | Cal-Poly University | |
| Jon Willard | University of South Carolina | |
| 2005 | Travis Anderson | Florida State University |
| David Cash | University of Florida | |
| Vladimir Frias | Florida International University | |
| Liam Shanahan | Western Kentucky University | |
| Anthony Moreda | Florida International University | |
| David Mixon | University of Louisiana-Monroe | |
| Ray Robles | Freed-Hardeman University | |
| Daniel Roberts | University of Louisiana-Monroe | |
| Eric Evans | Virginia Commonwealth Univ | |
| 2006 | Stephen Brock | University of Georgia |
| Chris Kirkland | University of Memphis | |
| Drew Cook | Florida A&M University | |
| Matt Creamer | Lyon College | |
| Jason Lewis | Louisiana State University | |
| Clay Long | Auburn University-Montgomery | |
| Clint Toomey | University of South Alabama | |
| Trevor Tyre | Troy University | |
| 2007 | Jesus Barroso | University of Tampa |
| Paul Gatchell | Troy University | |
| Blake Haagen | Univ of Louisiana-Lafayette | |
| Tom Hatcher | Florida Atlantic University | |
| Brian Hobbs | University of South Florida | |
| Trey Manz | University of South Florida | |
| Tyler Musselwhite | North Georgia College | |
| Logan Pierce | Valdosta State University | |
| Josh Storm | Troy University | |
| Brandon Street | Univ of Southeastern Louisiana | |
| David Thoms | University of Georgia | |
| 2008 | Einar Atencio | Lynn University |
| Adam Duvall | University of Louisville | |
| Matt Jackson | University of South Alabama | |
| Daniel Jones | Brewton-Parker College | |
| Drew Parker | Brewton-Parker College | |
| 2009 | Marc Bourgeois | University of So. Mississippi |
| Mark Ellis | University of So. Mississippi | |
| Jordan Lucas | Kent State University | |
| Chris Roach | Liberty University | |
| David Buchanan | Georgia State University | |
| Edmond Sparks | Louisiana State University | |
| Jason Townsend | University of Alabama | |
| J. B. Johnson | Kennesaw State University | |
| 2010 | Joey Rapp | University of Louisiana-Monroe |
| Garrett Baker | Liberty University | |
| Eric Sauls | University of Mississippi | |
| Aaron Etchison | University of Maryland | |
| Blake Newalu | University of Mississippi | |
| Austin Wright | University of Mississippi | |
| Duncan Midkiff | Georgia State University | |
| Brandon Gardner | Lambuth University | |
| Tyler Wilson | Freed-Hardman University | |
| Matt Singleton | Freed-Hardman University | |
| 2011 | Dillon Vitale | Saint Leo University |
| Tyrone Dawson | Toccoa Falls College | |
| Michael Revell | Saint Leo University | |
| Johnnie Cristi | Brewton Parker College | |
| Matt Marsh | Liberty University | |
| 2012 | Ladson Montgomery | Florida State University |
| Robby Coles | Florida State University | |
| Sasha LaGarde | Mercer University | |
| Chris Triplett | Georgia State University | |
| Marc Frazier | Nicholls State University | |
| Kaleb Barlow | University of West Florida | |
| Austin Southall | University of West Florida | |
| Brett Moore | University of North Alabama | |
| 2013 | Christian Correa | Nicholls State University |
| Mikel Belcher | Samford University | |
| Preston Johnson | University of South Carolina | |
| 2014 | Josh Merrigan | University of North Carolina |
| Taylor Lewis | University of Florida | |
| Ian Rice | University of Houston | |
| Chase Scott | University of So. Mississippi | |
| Bert Givens | Troy University | |
| Tucker Simpson | Troy University | |
| 2015 | Kevin Santa | University of Tampa |
| Lazaro Rivera | University of Tampa | |
| Anthony Burke | College of Charleston | |
| Gunnar McNeill | University of Kentucky | |
| Jacky Miles | Florida A&M University | |
| JoJo Durden | Florida A&M University | |
| Culver Lamb | Old Dominion University | |
| Tevelle Clark | North Carolina A&T University | |
| David Wright | Valdosta State University | |
| 2016 | Hudson Graham | Young Harris |
| Landon Faulkner | University of Arizona | |
| Wood Myers | Coastal Carolina | |
| Jay Estes | University of Auburn | |
| Michael Rojas | University of Auburn | |
| Maurice Cooley | Francis Marion | |
| Franklin Van Gurp | Florida International Univ | |
| Ty Russ | Florida A&M University | |
| Keiner Colmenarez | Tennessee Wesleyan | |
| Kyle Schweiger | University of Purdue | |
| 2017 | Trey Dawson | University of Kentucky |
| Jacob Silverstein | University of West Florida | |
| Robbie Knox | Lipscomb University | |
| Chris Clayton | Louisiana Tech University | |
| Roberto Negron | North Carolina A&T | |
| Brody Wofford | University of Central Florida | |
| Tyler Osik | Univeristy of Central Florida | |
| 2018 | Andrew Grogan | University of North Carolina |
| Trevor Holloway | University of Central Florida | |
| Alex Webb | Jacksonville State University | |
| Max Guzman | Faulkner University | |
| Morgan McCullough | University of Alabama | |
| Jared Padgett | Kansas University | |
| Phillip Sanderson | UNCG | |
| Jack Dellinger | Virginia Tech University | |
| Jordan Hollins | Texas Southern University | |
| Francisco Urbaez | Florida Atlantic University | |
| 2019 | Alex Arauz | Faulkner University |
| Logan Jarosz | North Carolina A&T | |
| Connor Kehl | Stetson University | |
| Parker Pillsbury | Southern Wesleyan University | |
| Jordan Anderson | University of Pittsburgh | |
| Jose Visaez | University of North Florida | |
| Andrew Baker | Auburn University | |
| 2020 | Corey Rosier | UNCG |
| Daniel Cerda | UNCG | |
| Daniel Blomgren | University of Michigan | |
| Andrew Keene | Lincoln Memorial University | |
| Nicholas Marrero | Hofstra University | |
| Christopher Williams | William Carey University | |
| Robert Bennett | Mercer University | |
| Michael Cullen | Rollins College | |
| Isaiah Byars | University of North Florida | |
| 2021 | Jozsef Rohrbacher | Mercer University |
| Cameron Gray | Troy University | |
| Matthew Garcia | Bethune-Cookman University | |
| Mark Black | Wake Forest University | |
| Bo Bonds | University of Louisiana | |
| Matthew Corlew | Eastern Kentucky University | |
| Dylan Goldstein | Florida Atlantic University | |
| Andre Tarver | Tennessee Wesleyan University | |
| Michael Esposito | University of South Carolina | |
| Lyle Miller-Green | Oklahoma State University | |
| Jake Simon | Fairleigh Dickinson University | |
| 2022 | Jake Holland | University of New Mexico |
| David Castillo | Southeastern University | |
| Dylan Eskew | University of South Carolina | |
| Zac Rice | UT-Martin | |
| Beckett White | University of Tampa | |
| Taylor Clapp | Flagler University | |
| Cesar Franco | Florida International University | |
| Shane Lewis | Troy University | |
| Colton Mercer | University of New Orleans | |
| 2023 | James Oman | University of North Florida |
| Andre Wojtarowicz | Morehead State University | |
| Peter Vazquez | Bethune-Cookman University | |
| Brady Browning | Western Kentucky University | |
| Dillon Haines | Dallas Baptist University | |
| Drew Howard | University of Tampa | |
| Carter Daniels | North Carolina A&T State University | |
| Brogan Napier | University of North Florida | |
| Robert Evans | Georgia State University | |
| Brandyn Durand | Bryant University | |
| Eli Berch | University of Mississippi | |
| Chase Scott | University of West Florida | |
| 2024 | Edian Espinal | University of Central Florida |
| Zach Kilby | Florida Atlantic University | |
| Brantley Willis | University of West Florida | |
| Jordan Taylor | Stetson University | |
| Elgin Bennett | Cal State - Bakersfield | |
| Rob Gordon | Jacksonville State University | |
| Zander Buchan | Jacksonville State University | |
| Knox Bennett | University of Georgia | |
| Brady McDevitt | University of West Georgia | |
| Ben Fielder | Florida Gulf Coast University | |
| Dawson Coe | Georgia Southern University | |
| Thasher Steed | Stetson University | |